Bertman’s Ballpark Mustard – The Real Deal
Posted by Kurt Smith
Even if you’re getting a loaded dog, you can’t pass up on Bertman’s ballpark mustard.
Somehow many people, myself included, have confused the “Stadium Mustard” made by Davis Foods with the authentic, served-since-the-League-Park-days Bertman’s Ballpark Mustard that goes on most hot dogs served at Progressive Field. (Note: those are affiliate links you’ve just passed, through which Ballpark E-Guides earns a commission. Thanks for your support!)
Joe Bertman’s spicy brown mustard has been part of Cleveland since the 1920s, while the “Stadium” version was made by another company smart enough to give it a similar name and make it available in retail stores first.
The two are similar in taste. Both are spicy Dijon deli-style mustards, better in quality than the French’s yellow usually found at the ballgame. Bertman’s takes pride in not watering down their mustard and using the finest vinegar; Stadium Mustard is pretty thick too. The only difference (according to a West Side Market vendor) is that the Stadium Mustard has cayenne in it.
To this day Stadium Mustard is easier to find in supermarkets and elsewhere, including in sports arenas outside of Progressive Field; I was unable to locate a bottle of Bertman’s in my travels except at the West Side Market. But despite their similar tastes, Bertman’s Ballpark Mustard is the real thing if you’re looking for authenticity.
It’s not that Stadium Mustard is bad by any means, just be sure you know what you’re getting.
(Note from Kurt: I received an e-mail about this piece from someone who remained anonymous, accusing me of “mustard propaganda”, which may be the funniest thing I’ve ever been accused of. As far as I can tell there aren’t any factual errors here, but if so feel free to call me out.)
Want to know more about Progressive Field? Sign up here for my completely free Progressive Field e-mail newsletter series, and score some seriously valuable info about tickets, seating, transportation and food…see you at the Yard!
Want to save money on baseball tickets, parking and everything else?
Check out my Fan Resources Page!!
If you go to baseball games, you’re going to spend money…on tickets, parking, food and souvenirs, not to mention hotels and travel expenses if you’re going on a baseball road trip.
I’m here to help…check out my Fan Resources page, where I share some of my favorite recommendations for buying tickets, booking baseball parking and saving on travel expenses.
Legal bit: My Fan Resources page contains affiliate links, so you can support this great website while making smart baseball decisions!